Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant - Petaluma (CA)

5 /5 Chrissy H: Came here to give it a try since we were craving pizza and have roots in Chicago. It has a really cool atmosphere and definitely gave me Chicago vibes. There are a lot of options on the menu for pizza and we chose the deep dish pizza with sausage, pepperoni and fresh tomatoes. It was delicious. We really enjoyed it. We tried the strawberry and original cheesecake for dessert. It was a little different for our liking but we still tried it anyways. The cookies are also very good and they are served warm with whipped cream. Overall, we really enjoyed this place. Being that we have kids, we were worried we would interrupt peoples dinner but its pretty open and was noisy so it made it easy for us not to have to stress about our kids being somewhat loud.

5 /5 Steve: Old Chicago is an institution in Petaluma. Theres a reason it’s been at the same location since 1978. What’s not to love about excellent pizza at a great location (former house of…shall we say ill repute). Seriously though, if you’re swinging through Petaluma and craving pizza, THIS IS the place. And that’s saying something since Petaluma is full of excellent food options (pizza too). I’ve had deep dish pizza IN Chicago, and they don’t hold a candle to Old Chicago. Ok, I’m a biased Petaluma native, but still. Show up early evening or you might be waiting. Expect to wait a few before the pizza arrives. I think reservations are only for 6+ people, and you definitely want to make said reservations for a large group. One last thing….you WILL leave full.

5 /5 Britteny *Rose*: Ive been here one time before about 10 years ago when I was in high school and its still just as good, if not better now that I eat a bigger variety of things! Our server was incredible! Very attentive and we were a decent sized party ( 8 adults and 2 kids) and we didnt have a single issue! She cut the first slices for all 3 pizzas we got and made it look so easy... when I tried to do it... sessshhhhh. Haha not as easy as it looks! Anyways, the garlic pesto bread was to die for! I would go back for that alone! I dont usually have it because I dont have a gallbladder and having anything that heavy would take me out but I had 0 issues which is unheard of! So Im thankful for that! The salad was awesome and they gave us so much ranch! I will be telling everyone e and anyone I know to give this a place a try if they havent! Its tucked away in downtown petaluma by the Mystic theater and parking is my only complaint but honestly after eating all that food the walk did me some good haha. Will deffinitly be returning and bragging to others so this place can continue to turn out incredible deep dish , delicious , works of art pizza!

4 /5 buyushay: Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant – 4.5 Stars We had a great experience overall at Old Chicago Pizza. The wait was a bit long, but once we were seated, things moved smoothly from there. The staff was friendly and attentive, and the food definitely made up for the delay. We ordered the thin crust, which was tasty and well-cooked, though in hindsight I wish I had followed my gut and gone for the thick crust—it looked amazing at other tables. The toppings were generous, piled on with no skimping, and the flavor had a nice tangy kick that set it apart from your average pizza joint. All in all, Old Chicago delivers a solid, satisfying meal in a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere. Definitely worth a visit—just come hungry and maybe a little patient!

5 /5 John Rodgers: Old Chicago Pizza. My father’s favorite pizza place! We first went here in 1979, a few years after we moved to Petaluma. The style, comfort and food have never changed! Easily to me the best pizza in Sonoma County! The deep-dish Chicago style pizza is…to…DIE FOR! It cannot be beat in my humble opinion. Great memories with my family here as well.