Petaluma Pie Company - Petaluma (CA)

5 /5 Jeff Downing: Definitely turn into this plaza when you see the Petaluma Pie signs. We tried the apple pecan crumble with caramel and the Elvis pie. Both were excellent. I live about an hour and half away and would consider driving up to get the apple pecan crumble for a special family gathering. Fantastic pie shop

5 /5 Michaelpone Sufian: Amazing pie with great ambience! We tried their Elvis pie and it was delicious! Would come back again. The porch to enjoy the pie was beautiful and enjoyable!

5 /5 Caitlin G.: I pre ordered a sweet potato pie with a side of whipped cream. The owner was very kind and went above and beyond accommodating me. The pie and whipped cream was incredible. Definitely will order more in the future.

5 /5 L S: This was THE best lemon meringue pie I’ve ever had in my whole life and I’m an old person!!! Lightest crust, lightest filling and fluffiest merengue EVER!!! Had to hold it down to keep it from floating away! PLUS…a fabulous cool jazz trio playing in the little outdoor dining area. Just a groovy scene in every way.

4 /5 John Rodgers: I have been wanting to try this place out as many of my friends recommended it. Up front let me say I do like this place. I can see some room for improvement but they knock out some pretty tasty fruit, cream and savory pies. The pies are all individual based, with hand pies for some of the savories, some of which resemble empanadas. Of the savory pies I tried I think I like the Jamaican Beef one the best. It had a unique blend of spices that I found worked quite well together. I also tried the Cheeseburger Pie, the Beef Bourguignon and the Pork Bun Pie. All a good mix of flavors and textures. The Pork Bun Pie, to me, is more of an egg roll pie…which is awesome by the way!!! When I think “Pork Bun” I think BBQ pork in a soft chewy bun. The fillings for this pie are pork, carrots and cabbage which are the main ingredients for an egg roll so If you go in expecting the Pork Bun to be BBQ Pork that is not the case….although it is a very good pie nonetheless! One that I would get again!! The Cheeseburger pie needs more cheese, and the seasoning is a little sweet but this is still a good showing. Maybe add some caramelized onions or something. Of the sweet pies I tried a few fruit pies and a cream pie. I had the strawberry Rhubarb, the Peach Berry Crumble and the Chocolate Coconut Cream pies. All were good. The Strawberry Rhubarb was good but kinda basic. The Peach Berry Crumble was amazing as was the Chocolate Coconut Cream pie. You need to really like coconut to enjoy this pie as it is LOADED with it! I love coconut so I thoroughly enjoyed this pie. All in all a very nice place for all kinds of pies!