Main Street Pizza and Tap - Mammoth Lakes (CA)

4 /5 Barry Hashimoto: Main Street Pizza & Tap is one of the few true lifelines on the eastern Sierra corridor—open until 10 p.m., reliably serving real food after long drives or longer descents. If you’re coming off trail northbound from the high country, this is where you stop. The location is dead center in Mammoth, right across from the Motel 6 and near convenience stores of all stripe. Inside, it’s loud, casual, a bit chaotic—arcade games humming, shuffleboard clacking, paper towels on the tables, bathrooms clean. The pizza is the reason to come: fantastic crust, well‑balanced toppings, and clearly hand‑made. It’s expensive—a large make‑your‑own will run you close to $40—but you’re not here for value. You’re here because you’re tired, hungry, and you want the best pizza between Tahoe and Bishop. Skip the wings: the chicken’s not great and the sauce doesn’t redeem it. The beer list is deep, sourced from east side breweries, and if you’ve got a couple hours to linger, it’s worth your time. Otherwise, grab your pie in a box and be on your way.

5 /5 Jose Hernandez: Great pizza and wings. We came in with a large group, the staff was really accommodating, allowing us to arrange tables and chairs as we wanted. Food was delicious, the service was fast and friendly, and you cant beat the vibe. Try the Tiramisu, absolutely delicious

2 /5 Hannah Andrews: Been here a number of times and first off, the pizza is pretty good. And they’ve got lots of beers on tap. HOWEVER there are a few staff members (Tanya and her lackey) who are extremely rude. When we first arrived (4:30pm) there were only 2 waitress and around 80% of the tables were not bussed and very messy… they have signs about being short staffed so it’s fine; we bussed a table and sat down. We had gotten here, ordered and were almost done eating (probably had been around 30 minutes), when another family arrived and needed a larger area to sit. Another waitress had arrived by this time, but multiple tables were still dirty. So the new customers started cleaning and moving the tables to make room for their party. While doing so, Tanya finally comes over and loudly makes the attitude filled passive aggressive statement “well if you had only waited, we would have been here and helped”. She kept making little comments so when she left I looked behind me and let the people know, the table had in fact been dirty for awhile and it wasn’t a big deal. Tanya, who happened to be in ear shot, comes back and continues with her attitude filled shots that she is worried about their safety (?) and doesn’t need the peanut gallery (me) chiming in. From there the passive aggression became very much active aggression where she told us to leave HER establishment and just generally rude things. She created such a scene the family of new customers ended up leaving without ordering. A very sweet waitress then came over and apologized for Tanya - only to then get yelled at herself by, you guessed it, Tanya. As we were leaving (literally outside) Tanya is there again and starts yelling at us to go back to LA and so cal. When I inform her we’re actually from Reno Nevada she says “even worse!” (which I beg to differ). I wanted to leave zero stars but there were a few very nice women who were very apologetic and seemed to take Tanya’s behavior very seriously so I bumped it to 2. All in all I’d say go here UNLESS Tanya is there to unleash her wrath on the next victim, then beware!