Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant - Eureka (CA)

5 /5 Aazhie Ryakes: Very cozy and mellow atmosphere. Restrooms are upstairs, old building is refurbished and very quaint. Service was super friendly and helpful. Small plates were great, all pasta and ravioli and everything was well plated and tasted fantastic. Creme Brule was great dessert to share!

5 /5 wayne: I LOVE Gabriels! I go here a lot because the staff is awesome, the food is fantastic and I enjoy the atmosphere. I highly recommend the gnocchi. I enjoyed reading through all the bad reviews of this place - not sure if those people are severely fragile or what, but Im sure they are making stuff up and looking for reasons to be offended. Ive gone here once or twice a month for 15 years and have never seen or experienced what some of these people are complaining about. kind of surprised they didnt claim to find glass in their food....

5 /5 Belen Vasquez: Outstanding Italian restaurant! Delicious, authentic food, great service, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Highly recommend, can’t wait to come back!

1 /5 Matthew Brockmeyer: So disapointed!! The pasta was cold. Not even slightly warm. The filet mignon was an excellent cut of meat but they ruined it by putting this vinegary, sweet coating on it that was disgusting. Steak sauce should be an option, putting that on a nice piece of meat is a crime, ordered medium rare, but it was well done. The cocktails were horrible. The old fashion had so much sugar in it you couldnt taste the bourbon, just sugar. Their house special cocktail, the dark and stormy was just ginger ale, barely any alcohol, if any, felt like I was drinking a bad soda full of bitters. Finally just switched to beer and a shot. Took an hour to get our food. Sad, was so looking forward to eating there.